Verified Document

Elsie Dennis Maynard, Deceased. Ralph Essay

The trustee took a fee from the percentage of rental income received and from a percentage of the real estate tax that was collected, and the beneficiaries objected to the trustee imposing a fee on the tax money received by the trust. Issue: Did the court err when it denied the trustee's motion for partial summary judgment in regards to an action that challenged in part the trustee's assessment of a fee on portions of trust income that was designated for payment of property taxes?

Law: Even though Haw. Rev. Stat. § 607-18 (1993) allowed for the fee on the tax money,...

Rev. Stat. § 560:7-205 (1993). Bremer v. Weeks, 104 Hawai'i 43; 51, 85 P.3d 150, 158 (2004); in re the Estate of Bishop, 53 Haw. At 605-06, 499 P.2d at 672; in re Wharton's Trust Estate, 28 Haw. At 509; Matthewson v. Aloha Airlines, Inc., 82 Hawai'i 57, 71, 919 P.2d 969, 983 (1996); Mahiai v. Suwa, 69 Haw. 349, 356-57, 742 P.2d 359, 366 (1987); Franks v. City and County of Honolulu, 74 Haw. 328, 335, 843 P.2d 668, 671-72 (1993).
Reasoning: Based on the plain language of…

Sources used in this document:
Law: Even though Haw. Rev. Stat. § 607-18 (1993) allowed for the fee on the tax money, the beneficiaries argued that there was a reasonable restriction on the fee imposed by reason of Haw. Rev. Stat. § 560:7-205 (1993). Bremer v. Weeks, 104 Hawai'i 43; 51, 85 P.3d 150, 158 (2004); in re the Estate of Bishop, 53 Haw. At 605-06, 499 P.2d at 672; in re Wharton's Trust Estate, 28 Haw. At 509; Matthewson v. Aloha Airlines, Inc., 82 Hawai'i 57, 71, 919 P.2d 969, 983 (1996); Mahiai v. Suwa, 69 Haw. 349, 356-57, 742 P.2d 359, 366 (1987); Franks v. City and County of Honolulu, 74 Haw. 328, 335, 843 P.2d 668, 671-72 (1993).

Reasoning: Based on the plain language of and the legislative history underlying HRS § 560:7-205, courts may review the reasonableness of a trustee's determination as to what constitutes income. In this case the trustee's determination of trust income was reasonable because income included real property taxes.

Holding: Vacated and remanded.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now